June 26, 2004
a believer is born

On more that one occasion on these pages I've declared my favorite album ever to be Wilco's "Yankee Hotel Foxtrot." It's a delirious album with gigantic hooks and melody hidden behind a strange wall of fuzz, distortion and sound effects. It was a quantum leap from the band's previous output and was an album that really suggested, nay required, careful repeated listenings. Even now, more than three years after we first got our hands on it, I still discover new corners and angles while marvelling at the songcraft.

I managed to get a copy of the band's latest, "A Ghost Is Born," about two months ago. I put it on, I think, expecting to hear more of the melodic output. I expected it to be comfortable, in other words. It wasn't. It was jarring. It was challenging. It was odd. As a result, I must admit that I gave up on it pretty quickly.

Fast forward to this week. After lead singer Jeff Tweedy's well-publicized stint in rehab the album finally sees an official release. It immediately found a nice snug spot on my iPod. I listened and listened and listened and somewhere along the way the light came on.

It's never going to be YHF. The hooks are all but gone. The lurking melody is non-existent. Wilco is now a band working in a different game. The opening track, "At Least That's What You Said" starts as mournful piano dirge that wouldn't be out of place on "Being There." But at the two minute mark it becomes a head-bobbing (and mind-boggling) Crazy Horse jam. By the third track, "Spiders (Kidsmoke)," we're almost being dared to tolerate ten minutes of chaos as Tweedy spits out non-sequiturs about Michigan beaches over randomly strummed guitars and throbbing synth loops.

Our reward for making it through "Spiders" is yet another challenge. Parts of "Muzzle of Bees" would fit well on Nick Drake's "Bryter Layter." The end, however, would almost fit on Lou's "Metal Machine Music." I told ya it was a challenge.

But suddenly the onslaught takes a break. From the Sesame Street bounce of "Hummingbird" until the almost flawless "Theologians" six songs later, things become much more tame. There's still nothing as immediate as YHF's "Pot Kettle Black" or "Jesus, etc." but there are plenty of interesting diversions and some near hooks.

Things come to a screeching halt, though, with the already infamous "More Than You Think." Lou once said of the aforementioned "Metal Machine Music" that "anyone who gets to side four is dumber than I am." Tweedy's pretty much said the same of this track. The first three minutes are a somber affair seemingly about a migraine headache. The next twelve minutes consist of one single note drawn out, oscillated, distorted and joined by feedback. Anyone who finds any enjoyment whatsoever in it has serious issues. It's patently absurd.

The album draws to a close with the only real radio-friendly track. "The Last Greats" is about as close to alt.country as Wilco 2004 gets. A very palatable end to a challenging album.

In the end, it's a work that I marvel at. It's ambitious, it's thought-provoking, it's a challenge. It's also fairly frustrating and fairly schizophrenic. Somehow I think that's exactly what they were hoping for...

Posted by mikewolf at June 26, 2004 04:42 PM
Comments

Good to hear that you gave it another chance.

There was a time when I took a little stock in what the pretentious folks at Pitchfork had to say. Those days are long gone.

I love your choice word to describe the album as a "challenge". I've discussed this album ad nauseum with a few friends and the one difference that we tend to find in listening to Wilco albums is the reward of peeling back the layers to find the album's "voice".

Once that "voice" is discovered, whether it be in your car on the highway, or with your headphones droning away at work, it's a wonderful feeling.

BTW, seeing your Sesame Street reference reminds of its unmistakable theme song used in the melody for Outta Mind (Outta Sight).

PS It's "Late" Greats.

Posted by: Cory on June 27, 2004 03:17 AM

Finding "the voice" is a great discription, Cory. Thanks for the title fix.

On Pitchfork: I actually use them for a starting off point an awful lot. Are they a bit pompous? Absolutely. But they're also on the mark more often than not. I don't let anyone "shape" my opinions but I guess I need someone to help weed out the crap from time-to-time.

All this is to say that I don't think that their review of AGIB is that far off. Rob Mitchum is a big fan and has been writing about the band for quite a while. There are too many silly noodling solos. The writing isn't as inspired as their past work (as a test, what song will you remember the imagery of after you turn the record off? I submit none.). Does that make it a bad album? Of course not. That just makes it not "Summerteeth" and not "YHF.".

Posted by: mrw on June 27, 2004 11:05 AM

It almost sounds like you guys are talking about an undiscovered Peter Gabriel-era Genesis album...

Posted by: Frankenstein on June 27, 2004 01:51 PM

It was my theory for a long time that "Metal Machine Music" actually didn't have a fourth side. I mean, if they left it blank, who would know?

Turns out I was wrong, but I can't fathom to this day why anyone bothered to find out.

However, MMM was my second most effective record to get my roommates out of the room for a while. The first one, you ask? Oh, c'mon, guess. No seriously, what would you use?

Posted by: Linus on June 29, 2004 03:57 PM

>However, MMM was my second most
>effective record to get my roommates
>out of the room for a while. The first one,
>you ask?

Ca Plane Pour Moi?

> Oh, c'mon, guess.

Hey, I just did!

>No seriously, what would you use?

My college roomate used to play the Outlaws' "Green Grass and High Tides" over and over, so basically anything in my collection served to drive him from the room. Let's say it was X-Ray Spex.

I like Mike's theory that Tweedy was born to make records for the era of CD skip buttons. ;^) The album is pretty good, apart from the parts where he's daring us to switch it off. He's a tad too mopey for my tastes, and I've admittedly got a problem w/ how he discards musicians.

Posted by: Vernam on July 1, 2004 02:43 PM

Ca Plane Pour Moi was anthemic back then; I graduated from college in the Class of 87, though I started with an earlier class. Counting from high school I did the 8-year plan.

No, the #1 rommate-clearing record of the time was the eponymous Yoko Ono double album. It would probably still work.

Posted by: Linus on July 2, 2004 03:56 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?